Gas vs Electric Furnace
Lower install cost vs lower operating cost—which matters more for your situation?
Quick Answer: Gas costs more to install but 2-3x less to operate. Over 10 years, gas saves $6,000-$10,000. Electric only makes sense without gas service. For Charlotte, consider a heat pump—most efficient for our mild winters.
5-Star Rated
Google Verified
445+ Reviews
18+ Years
Family-Owned
Since 2008
Financing Available
Low Monthly Payment
Starting at $45/mo
Same-Day Service
No Extra Charge
Skilled Technicians
Our Charlotte Recommendation
Heat Pump (Best) or Gas Furnace (Traditional)
Charlotte's mild winters make heat pumps the most efficient choice—they cost less to operate than both gas and electric furnaces. If you prefer traditional furnace heating and have gas service, gas is the clear winner over electric for operating costs. Electric furnaces make sense only if you have no gas line AND don't want a heat pump.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Category | Gas | Electric | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Installation Cost | $4,000-$8,000 | $3,000-$5,000 | Electric |
| Operating Cost (Charlotte) | $600-$1,000/year | $1,200-$2,000/year | Gas |
| Energy Efficiency | 80-98% AFUE | 100% AFUE | Electric |
| Heating Speed | Fast (110-140°F air) | Slower (90-110°F air) | Gas |
| Lifespan | 15-20 years | 20-30 years | Electric |
| Safety | CO risk (with maintenance, minimal) | No combustion risks | Electric |
| Maintenance | Annual required | Minimal | Electric |
| Environmental Impact | Burns fossil fuel | Depends on grid source | Tie |
| Requires Gas Line | Yes | No | Electric |
| 10-Year Total Cost | $10,000-$18,000 | $15,000-$25,000 | Gas |
10-Year Cost Comparison
Gas Furnace
Install: $6,000
Annual Operating: $800
$14,000
10-Year Total
Electric Furnace
Install: $4,000
Annual Operating: $1,600
$20,000
10-Year Total
Heat Pump
Install: $10,000
Annual Operating: $500
$15,000
10-Year Total
*Estimates based on average Charlotte home. Actual costs vary.
Pros & Cons
Gas Furnace
✓ Pros
- •Lower operating costs—2-3x cheaper to run than electric
- •Heats faster—delivers 110-140°F air vs 90-110°F
- •Better for very cold weather performance
- •Lower 10-year total cost of ownership
- •Works during power outages (with generator)
- •Widely available parts and service
✗ Cons
- •Higher installation cost ($4,000-$8,000)
- •Requires gas line (expensive to add if none)
- •Annual maintenance required for safety
- •Small CO risk (mitigated with detectors)
- •Burns fossil fuel
- •Shorter lifespan than electric (15-20 vs 20-30 years)
Electric Furnace
✓ Pros
- •Lower installation cost ($3,000-$5,000)
- •No gas line needed
- •100% efficient—all energy becomes heat
- •Longer lifespan (20-30 years)
- •No combustion = no CO risk
- •Minimal maintenance required
- •Safer—no flame or gas
✗ Cons
- •Much higher operating cost (2-3x gas)
- •Slower heating—lower temperature air
- •High electricity bills in winter
- •Less effective in extreme cold
- •Depends on electricity (no power = no heat)
- •10-year cost significantly higher than gas
Which Is Best For Your Situation?
Have gas line, want lowest bills
Gas operating cost is 2-3x lower.
No gas line available
Adding gas line costs $1,500-$3,000+.
Tight budget for installation
Lower upfront cost by $1,000-$3,000.
Plan to stay 10+ years
Lower operating cost wins long-term.
Environmental priority
Most efficient option, uses electricity.
Concerned about safety
No combustion, no CO risk.
Very cold climate (not Charlotte)
Better performance below 30°F.
Mild climate like Charlotte
Best efficiency for mild winters.
Gas vs Electric Furnace FAQ
Is gas or electric furnace cheaper to run?
Gas is significantly cheaper—typically 2-3x less. In Charlotte, expect $600-$1,000/year for gas vs $1,200-$2,000/year for electric. Over 10 years, gas saves $6,000-$10,000 in operating costs despite higher installation.
Which furnace lasts longer?
Electric furnaces last longer (20-30 years vs 15-20 for gas) because they have fewer moving parts and no combustion components to wear out. However, the higher operating cost often offsets this advantage.
Is electric furnace safer than gas?
Yes—electric furnaces have no combustion, no flame, and no carbon monoxide risk. Gas furnaces are safe with proper maintenance and CO detectors, but electric eliminates those concerns entirely.
Why is electric furnace 100% efficient but costs more?
Efficiency rating measures how much input energy becomes heat—electric converts 100%. But electricity costs 3-4x more per BTU than natural gas in NC, so 100% efficiency of expensive fuel still costs more than 95% efficiency of cheap fuel.
Should I get electric furnace if I don't have gas?
Consider a heat pump instead. Heat pumps are 2-3x more efficient than electric furnaces and provide AC too. Electric furnaces make sense only for very cold climates or as backup heat for heat pumps.
How much does it cost to add a gas line?
Adding a gas line for a furnace costs $1,500-$3,000+ depending on distance from the meter and local requirements. Factor this into your decision if you don't have gas service.
What about a heat pump vs gas furnace?
In Charlotte's mild climate, heat pumps are often the best choice—more efficient than gas for heating and they provide AC. See our Heat Pump vs Furnace comparison for details.
Which is better for the environment?
It depends on your electricity source. In NC (mixed grid), a high-efficiency gas furnace may have similar or lower emissions than electric. Heat pumps are generally the greenest option.
Need Help Deciding?
Free consultation. We'll recommend what's best for your home and budget—not what pays us more.
Licensed & Insured•Same-Day Service